Technological breakthroughs

Rare Earth Elements Recovered from Apatite Ore Using Thermal Processing Instead of Acid Leaching

02:02 PM @ Tuesday - 03 November, 2026

Researchers in Norway and Sweden have developed a method for recovering rare earth elements (REEs) from apatite concentrate without acid leaching. Instead, the ore is treated at high temperatures to form a slag in which rare earth elements are concentrated and crystallized, allowing them to be separated mechanically.

The approach is expected to reduce the amount of hazardous wastewater compared with acid-based processes, while also opening up the possibility of recovering phosphorus in gaseous form for further use. However, its high energy consumption and the actual recovery rate of rare earth elements still require further assessment before industrial application can be considered.

Why Are Additional Sources of Rare Earth Elements Needed?

Rare earth elements are a group of critical elements used in a wide range of technologies, from permanent magnets, batteries and catalysts to polishing materials and displays.

The supply of these elements is currently concentrated in a small number of countries. According to the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), China, Vietnam, Brazil and Russia are among the countries with the world's largest rare earth reserves. Europe, meanwhile, has limited resources, while its capacity to recover rare earth elements from end-of-life products remains low.

This has prompted Europe to seek alternative sources of raw materials, including recovering rare earth elements from waste streams and ores that are already being mined for other purposes.

One research direction is to make use of apatite ore—the main raw material for phosphate fertilizer production—which can contain significant amounts of rare earth elements.

Which Rare Earth Elements Are Found in Apatite?

The raw material used in the study was obtained from ore residues at the Kiruna mine in Sweden, operated by mining company LKAB.

Previous research by the team showed that the four main rare earth elements present in this material are lanthanum, cerium, neodymium and yttrium. They are mainly distributed among apatite, monazite and allanite minerals.

However, recovering rare earth elements directly from the concentrate presents a major challenge: its high phosphorus content results in an extremely high melting temperature.

To address this problem, the researchers first had to remove part of the phosphorus.

More Than 90% of Phosphorus Removed at 2,000°C

The scientists used silicon and carbon to reduce phosphorus in the concentrate. The mixture was heated to approximately 2,000°C for one hour.

This process removed more than 90% of the phosphorus. As a result, the proportion of rare earth elements in the remaining material nearly doubled compared with the starting material.

After reducing the phosphorus content, the team proceeded to the next step: producing a special type of slag designed to concentrate the rare earth elements.

Creating a “Master Slag” to Concentrate Rare Earth Elements

The treated concentrate was mixed with neodymium oxide and several other compounds at ratios calculated based on the calcium oxide–silicon oxide–neodymium oxide system.

The mixture was then melted, crushed and remelted several times to produce a homogeneous material known as a master slag.

Before using actual ore, the researchers conducted experiments with synthetic slag made from pure chemicals. This approach allowed them to control the composition and reduce costs while determining the most suitable ratios.

The results showed that a composition containing approximately 10% neodymium by weight provided the best conditions for forming the desired crystalline phase. The corresponding mixture consisted of 47.5% calcium oxide, 42.5% silicon oxide and 10% neodymium oxide.

The experiments were conducted in a vacuum induction furnace under an argon atmosphere to minimize reactions with oxygen.

Rare-Earth-Bearing Crystals “Grow” Inside the Slag

A key aspect of the study was monitoring how rare-earth-bearing crystals formed as the master slag gradually cooled.

The researchers collected samples at various temperatures, ranging from 1,380 to 1,600°C, with holding times ranging from several minutes to one hour. The samples were then analyzed using X-ray diffraction, electron microscopy and thermal analysis techniques.

The results showed that a crystalline phase containing calcium, neodymium and silicon formed as expected. This phase can effectively incorporate rare earth elements in a stable form, creating conditions that could allow them to be separated from the remaining slag.

The researchers also observed that crystallization occurred in two stages.

Initially, numerous very small crystals appeared in the molten slag. After approximately five minutes, the crystals began to grow. With continued heat treatment, the number of smaller crystals gradually decreased while some larger crystals continued to develop.

This phenomenon is known as Ostwald ripening. The process can be visualized as smaller crystal particles gradually dissolving, with the material subsequently being transferred to larger particles. As a result, the number of crystals decreases while their average size increases.

The team also found that at lower holding temperatures, the amount of crystalline phase formed tended to increase because the solubility of this phase in the molten slag decreased.

No Acid Needed, with Potential for Additional Phosphorus Recovery

According to the authors, the thermal-processing approach offers two notable advantages over acid-based rare earth recovery.

First, the process does not require acid leaching, potentially reducing the amount of chemical wastewater that needs to be treated.

Second, phosphorus removed during the reduction step can be converted into a gas and potentially recovered as a useful product rather than simply becoming waste.

However, the process also generates phosphine gas, which is toxic and flammable. If the technology is scaled up, gas collection and treatment would need to be subject to strict controls.

Energy Remains the Main Bottleneck

The new method cannot yet be considered a complete solution.

The biggest obstacle is that the phosphorus-reduction step requires temperatures of around 2,000°C, implying very high energy consumption. For industrial deployment, researchers will need to determine whether comparable results can be achieved at lower temperatures.

Another limitation is that the experiments lasted no more than one hour. Because the number of samples was limited, crystal formation and growth did not reach full equilibrium. As a result, the researchers were not yet able to develop a complete kinetic model for predicting the process at larger scales.

Most importantly, the study has so far demonstrated the ability to enrich rare earth elements, rather than determining precisely what percentage of the rare earth elements initially present can ultimately be recovered as a product.

Next Step: Separating the Crystals from the Slag

The researchers propose further experiments at lower temperatures, with longer holding times, while monitoring crystal formation under continuous cooling conditions.

Another research direction is to find ways of recovering phosphorus as a value-added product rather than simply treating it as an exhaust gas.

Once rare-earth-bearing crystals of sufficient size have been produced, the next step will be to develop a method for separating them from the remaining slag. The researchers expect that differences in particle size and density could potentially be exploited for this purpose.

More importantly, a direct comparison between thermal processing and acid leaching is needed, covering everything from rare earth recovery efficiency and energy consumption to waste-treatment requirements and costs.

Potential for Apatite Ore

The study was conducted using apatite ore from Sweden, but this approach could also attract interest in regions where apatite is mined and processed for fertilizer production.

Rare earth elements can occur naturally in apatite ore at varying concentrations depending on the source. If they can be recovered during ore processing, plants could produce not only phosphate products but also an additional source of raw materials for high-tech industries.

This is particularly noteworthy because rare-earth-bearing material may otherwise be regarded merely as an accompanying component or waste stream of ore processing.

However, turning the concept into an industrial process will require three major challenges to be addressed: reducing the processing temperature and energy consumption, determining the actual rare earth recovery rate, and developing a cost-effective crystal separation stage.

If these barriers can be overcome, thermal processing could provide an alternative route for recovering rare earth elements from apatite ore without relying entirely on acid leaching, while making better use of a resource currently mined primarily for fertilizer production.

Source: Sun, T., Rodahl, F., Kennedy, M.W. & Aune, R.E., Study of a Master Slag Production Based on Apatite Concentrate with the Objective of Rare Earth Element Recovery, Journal of Sustainable Metallurgy, 12, 316–330 (2026), DOI: 10.1007/s40831-025-01316-8. The study was conducted at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology and KTH Royal Institute of Technology as part of the EU-funded REEcover project, using material supplied by mining company LKAB (Sweden).

Content editor: Bảo Hiền